New York Red Bulls
Vanzeir D.
(PK)
Miranchuk Al.
Elias Manoel
Mosquera E.
Elias Manoel
| New York Red Bulls | 2-2 | Atlanta Utd | |
| 31' |
Vanzeir D.
| 1-0 | |
| 45' | 1-1 |
(PK)
Miranchuk Al. |
|
| 87' |
(Missed PK)
Elias Manoel
| 1-1 | |
| 90' | 1-2 |
Mosquera E. |
|
| 90' |
Elias Manoel
| 2-2 | |